Don’t Scan Me!
The Online Safety Bill’s spy clause will outsource surveillance to messaging apps.
A ‘spy clause‘ in the Online Safety Bill introduces scanning of our private messages. Clause 122 of the bill empowers Ofcom to issue notices to providers of messaging services. These notices require them to develop and deploy software that will scan your phone for illicit material.
Message scanning is an expansion of mass surveillance. Millions of people use these services daily. Scanning phone messages breaks the promise of confidentiality and undermines our security.
The spy clause unlocks the security measures built into your phone. Some providers of end-to-end encrypted messaging such as Signal and WhatsApp have said they will withdraw their service from the UK, rather than undermine security.
Join our campaign
Support our campaign to prevent client-side scanning from compromising your privacy.
Take ActionWrite to your mp
Use our tool to tell your MP about your concerns with the Online Safety Bill.
Take ActionTHE SPY CLAUSE
If the securocrats get their way, they will turn your phone into a spy in your pocket. They will scan your private messages for illicit content without judicial oversight. There is a scary parallel here with the surveillance society created in places like China. If we accept the principle of mass surveillance of our private messages, it opens the door to creeping authoritarianism.
Online Safety Bill: Civil society organisations urge UK to protect global digital security and safeguard private communication
Open letter to the UK government from over 80 national and international civil society organisations, academics and cyberexperts raising concerns about the serious threat to the security of private and encrypted messaging posed by the Online Safety Bill.
Find Out MoreFree expression online
11 May 2023 By Pam Cowburn
Online Safety Bill: A Danger to Democracy
The campaign group, Republic have called for an investigation into the arrest of eight of their members, including Chief Executive Graham Smith, ahead of the organisation’s planned protest of the King’s coronation.
Find Out More
Mass Surveillance
04 Aug 2022 By Dr Monica Horten
The Online Safety Bill puts a spy in your pocket
The deployment of client-side scanning on private messaging systems was trailed in a research paper published by the technical directors of GCHQ and the National Cybersecurity Centre (NCSC).
Find Out MoreMass Surveillance
12 Dec 2022 By Dr Monica Horten
Online Safety Bill: Triple shield or triple surveillance?
Update on the Parliamentary amendments
The Online Safety Bill is back in Parliament.
Find Out MoreMass Surveillance
24 Nov 2022 By Dr Monica Horten
Global encryption coalition warns of Online Safety Bill dangers
70 organizations, cyber security experts, and elected officials sign open letter expressing dangers of Online Safety Bill
On 24 November, seventy civil society organizations, companies, elected officials, and cybersecurity experts, including Global Encryption Coalition members, published an open letter to British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak highlighting their concerns with the threat that the United Kingdom’s Online Safety Bill poses to end-to-end encryption.
Find Out More
Policy Hub
Who’s checking on your phone in private online spaces?
Private messaging in the Online Safety Bill and the impact on end-to-end encryption
Read our policy briefing
The Story So Far
Omnishambles over encrypted messages continues
At the eleventh hour of the Online Safety Bill’s passage through Parliament, the Government has found itself claiming to have both conceded that it won’t do anything stupid regarding encrypted messages, and that it may well press ahead with dangerous technologies if it wants to.More Information
18 April, 2023
Policy briefing – Online Safety Bill – House of Lords Committee Stage
CIVIL SOCIETY COMMITTEE STAGE BRIEFING ON THE ONLINE SAFETY BILL FOR HOUSE OF LORDS: ILLEGAL CONTENT SAFETY DUTIES AND PRIOR RESTRAINT – Supported by Wikimedia UK, Index on Censorship, and Open Rights Group.
Find Out More
16 March, 2023
Campaign Pack – Online Safety Bill
A guide for ORG supporters and activists who want to take action to protect their digital rights from the Online Safety Bill
Campaign Pack on the Online Safety Bill for ORG campaignersAuthor – James Baker – james.
Find Out More
16 January, 2023
Online Safety Bill third reading briefing
Briefing to inform the Third Reading debate in the House of Commons on 17 January 2023
Unintended consequences of the Online Safety Bill mean a trio of surveillance, prior restraint of speech, and restriction on access to online content and services.
Find Out More
16 January, 2023
Policy briefing – Criminal liability for content harmful to children
A Policy briefing
Criminal liability for content harmful to children
Amendment NC2 Sir William Cash and Miriam Cates
Drafted by Dr Monica Horten – 16 Jan 2023
The Amendment is not about child protection.
Find Out More
05 January, 2023
The Online Safety Bill – Sector Support Roundtable
In September 2022, Open Rights Group convened a discussion between privacy and data protection experts and other civil society professionals exploring the nexus between privacy, protection from online abuse and freedom of expression.
Find Out More
29 June, 2022
Submission to Parliament on Online Safety Bill
SUBMISSION TO PARLIAMENT Addressing automated, arbitrary, algorithmic censorship in the Online Safety BillJune 2022
Contents
About Open Rights Group 2
Addressing automated, arbitrary algorithmic censorship 2
Our concerns and recommendations 2
Summary 3
Automated censorship and arbitrary restrictions 4
Content moderation systems 5
Arbitrary restrictions 6
Why prevent has a special meaning (prior restraint) 9
Hands, face, age-gate 9
Ministerial powers to interfere with speech 10
Chat controls, to do lists and the spy in the your pocket 11
User Dis- Empowerment 13
Rights for online speech 13
Procedural safeguards and effective remedies 15
User experiences of restrictive content moderation measures 15
Procedural safeguards against arbitrary take-downs 16
About Open Rights Group
Open Rights Group (ORG) is the leading UK-based digital campaigning organisation.
Find Out More
27 April, 2022
Online Safety Bill Second Reading briefing
ORG analysis and highlights concerning the Online Safety Bill and its adverse impact on human rights and the free internet
About Open Rights Group
Open Rights Group (ORG) is the leading UK-based digital campaigning organisation.
Find Out More
07 February, 2022
Experts challenge Govt’s anti-encryption campaign
Leading cybersecurity experts and human rights activists say scaremongering tactics being used to mislead the public and make bogus case for weakening encryption.
Find Out More
Press Releases
18 April, 2023
WhatsApp, Signal and Element: Online Safety Bill ‘poses an unprecedented threat to the privacy, safety and security of every UK citizen’
Open Rights Group welcomes calls by WhatsApp, Signal and Element for a re-think of government proposals that could force them to undermine the encryption of their services.
Find Out More
12 January, 2023
Changes to Online Safety Bill embed power of tech companies, and do little for free speech
In the latest version of the Online Safety Bill, a provision governing so-called “legal but harmful” content for adults has been removed.
Find Out More
30 November, 2022
Chat monitoring sneaked into Online Safety Bill through back door measure
For immediate release
The Open Rights Group’s policy manager on Freedom of Expression, Dr.
Find Out More
28 November, 2022
Online Safety Bill sinking under flood of amendments
Attempts to solve social problems with draconian regulation of internet services won’t help victims.
Find Out More
16 November, 2022
Online Safety Bill a threat to human rights warn campaigners
Civil liberties groups have warned that the Online Safety Bill will fundamentally undermine human rights in the UK.
Find Out More