January 21, 2009 | Jim Killock

Consumers, citizens and information professionals around the world unite to condemn copyright extension

Update (22.01.09): The European Bureau of Library, Information and Documentation Associations (EBLIDA) and French digital rights activists La Quadrature du Net have added their support to the joint statement,


Today, organisations representing consumers, citizens and libraries around the world united to condemn copyright term extension in Europe. The joint statement was sent to MEPs who sit on the committees that will decide the flawed Term Extension Directive's future. It read:

The European Parliament is being asked to nearly double the term of copyright afforded to sound recordings. Industry lobbyists suggest that extending copyright term will help increase the welfare of performers and session musicians. But the Term Extension Directive, which will be voted on by the Legal Affairs Committee in a few weeks' time, will do no such thing. Instead it will hand millions of euros over to the world's four major record labels, money that will come direct from the pockets of European consumers. The majority (80%) of recording artists will receive between €0.50 - €26 a year.

Helping poor recording artists is a commendable aim. But the Term Extension Directive insults these good intentions. Andrew Gowers, former editor of the Financial Times, who conducted an independent review into the intellectual property framework for the UK Government in 2006, has called it out of tune with reality. Professor Bernt Hugenholtz, who advises the European Commission on intellectual property issues, has called it a deliberate attempt on behalf of the Commission to mislead Europe's Parliament. If passed, the Term Extension Directive will have serious consequences for Europe's IP policy.

  • Any extension of copyright term will take money directly from consumers' pockets. It will also consign a large part of Europe's cultural heritage to a commercial vacuum.
  • Europe's leading IP research centres have clearly shown the proposal does not do what it purports to do - help the poorest performers. It is simply a windfall for the owners of large back catalogues and the top earning performers.
  • The proposal will undermine public respect for copyright law and introduce an unworkable and unproven framework for copyright, at the very time when Europe's copyright framework needs to be at its most robust.

We therefore ask you to vote to reject this directive, as per Amendment 15 of the ITRE opinion (David Hammerstein).

As well as EFF, Open Rights Group and Consumer Focus, the statement was signed by BEUC, the umbrella organisation representing 42 consumer rights organisations in Europe, EDRI, the umbrella organisation representing 29 privacy and civil rights organisations across Europe, and IFLA, the umbrella organisation representing over 650,000 library and information professionals worldwide. You can download the full statement here.

Thanks to everyone for the great response to the cartoon we released last week. It's already had over 14,000 views, been translated into Spanish, and it's currently eleventh in YouTube's top favourited News and Politics videos (not bad for the week Obama got inaugurated). But the battle is by no means won yet - please, if you can, come to our event in Brussels next week, or invite your MEP to come on your behalf.


Comments (5)

  1. The Open Rights Group : Blog Archive » Sound Copyright conference attacks the “fairy tale” of copyright term extension.:
    Feb 11, 2009 at 10:24 PM

    [...] committee will likely vote to push the proposal to a full plenary vote in Parliament in March against fierce opposition from the representatives of 42 consumer rights organisations (BEUC), 29 privacy and civil rights [...]

  2. Auteursrecht op geluid | eco.nomie.nl:
    Feb 06, 2009 at 08:15 PM

    [...] Dat plan om het copyright op muziek in de hele EU zo’n beetje te verdubbelen vanaf de huidige 50 jaar, [...]

  3. Fractured Bloughts » Culture Featured People » Sound of Copyright:
    Feb 06, 2009 at 03:03 PM

    [...] http://www.openrightsgroup.org/2009/01/21/consumers-citizens-and-information-professionals-around-th... (5) [...]

  4. ICMPECHO · Sound Copyright!:
    Jan 28, 2009 at 01:42 AM

    [...] - EU Copyright Extension: Help MEPs Hear the Other Side ORG - Consumers, citizens and information professionals around the world unite to condemn copyright ... Ars Technica - EU pays for, then ignores study on copyright extension TheRegister - EU commissioner [...]

  5. as days pass by, by Stuart Langridge — The European Parliament and the Term Extension Directive:
    Jan 28, 2009 at 12:41 PM

    [...] (In the UK, you can do this through WriteToThem.) My letter is below; it takes various ideas from Open Rights Group writings and Gary Fleming’s similar [...]



This thread has been closed from taking new comments.