call +44 20 7096 1079
September 14, 2005 | Suw Charman Anderson

Framing DRM

Kevin Marks uses Lakovian frames* to explain what's wrong with DRM to five different audiences, of which the first two:

Computer Users: DRM turns your computer against you
I know sometimes it seems like your computer has it's own agenda, when it refuses to print or copy or find your documents. DRM does this on purpose. It is designed to stop you copying and pasting, printing and sharing things. I don't think you want this.

Computer Scientists: DRM will fail through emulation
One of the basic precepts of Computer Science is the Church-Turing thesis, which shows that any computer can emulate any other one. This is not theory, but something we all use every day, whether it is Java virtual machines, or CPU's emulating older ones for software compatibility.

The corollary of this is that code can never really know where it is running. For a rock solid example, look at MAME, the Multi-Arcade Machine Emulator, that runs almost any video game from the last 30 years. The games think you have paid a quarter when you press the '5' key.

I like this sort of comparative re-framing of debates. It provides for a variety of different viewpoints, acknowledges that there's more than one way to think about these issues and allows you to hit one very big bird many times with several well-framed stones.

* 'Frames' are a way of presenting information or rhetoric that is sympathetic to a specific audience's paradigm. George Lakoff applied frames to political communications thus illuminating how language is used by politicians to very subtly reinforce their point.

google plusdeliciousdiggfacebookgooglelinkedinstumbleupontwitteremail


Comments (3)

  1. Julian Bond:
    Sep 14, 2005 at 08:13 AM

    Framing is all important. One of our major challenges is to switch the framing of the debates given to the public at large from "pirates" to "fair use". From "content ownership" to "Sorry you can't record this program so you can watch it on another day".

  2. Chris Williams:
    Sep 16, 2005 at 11:39 AM

    So we need to bang on to users about DRM being 'hijacking' - these people want to hijack your computer.

  3. Calum Leslie:
    Sep 23, 2005 at 05:23 PM

    It's not even just that



This thread has been closed from taking new comments.