Supporter Newsletter

October 31, 2008 | Michael Holloway

Supporter update - October 2008

Welcome to the latest Open Rights Group supporter update. In this edition:

- Recruiting the next Executive Director - - Piracy vs Obscurity - - Freedom Not Fear - - Sound Copyright - - Consultations - - Volunteering - - Press - - Events - inc. date for ORG Xmas party - - Mini Links - - Thanks -


  • Recruiting the next Executive Director
  • After two great years as Executive Director of ORG, Becky Hogge will be moving on early in 2009. This means we're recruiting for the next Executive Director. The job advert and full job description are on the website. Please push the word about this vacancy out across your networks and particularly to any suitable candidates you may know. We're all immensely proud of the progress Becky has made both on specific copyright and surveillance campaigns, and more generally in building a financially sustainable basis for ORG. We wish her the very best for her future projects.

  • Piracy vs Obscurity with our patron, Neil Gaiman
  • In a spooky crypt in old London town, Neil Gaiman spoke to an audience of nearly 200 about piracy from the perspective of a creator, what it means to be one of the tribe of readers, and why most people discover their favourite authors for free. The talk was really well-received, as were the raffle prizes. Thanks to the ORG volunteers who made sure everyone had a grand evening. An audio recording of the event is available.

  • Freedom Not Fear: the Big Picture on Parliament Square
  • ORG teamed up with No2ID on a sunny Saturday in Parliament Square and constructed a 4x5m collage of the hundreds of photos of UK surveillance state ephemera you uploaded to Flickr. The huge, Big-Brother-inspired image expressed the concern that although we each see only incremental invasions of our privacy, put together, these creeping changes constitute a wholesale shift towards a society predicated on fear rather than freedom. If you want to use the image in your own projects, you can get it from the wiki.

  • Make sure MPs hear your views on copyright term extension: get in touch today
  • The European Parliament is preparing its opinion on the European Commission's flawed proposal to extend the term of copyright protection for sound recordings. Your MEPs need to know that their voters are concerned and paying attention so get in touch. To help you we've prepared a guide to lobbying your MEPs and a briefing pack. Lobbyists for term extension are already at work but your voice is stronger than any professional advocate. We can't overstate it: the best thing you can do to stop this is to let your MEPs hear your side. See the blog for extensive links to resources to help you protect the public domain.

  • Consultation submissions: Data Retention and illicit p2p
  • This month we've produced submissions to two government consultations on the Data Retention Directive and illicit p2p filesharing. We criticised the Data Retention Directive in relation to basic human rights and the uncertainty it introduces to UK law, suggesting we should follow Austria and other EU member states in refusing to implement it. Our p2p submission argues that it's music industry innovation that will slow illicit filesharing, and not legislative intervention.

  • Next volunteer meeting / ORG Day
  • If you want to get more involved with digital rights and ORG then your first stop should be a volunteer meeting, where we run through current volunteer works and dish out new tasks. We have close to 100 regular volunteer contributors. Please put your name up on the wiki if you intend to attend. The next meet will be at 1830 on Wednesday 19 November, at our office, which is 7th floor, 100 Grays Inn Road, London WC1X 8AL. As usual, we'll have the IRC and conference call running so that non-locals can participate. This volunteer meeting is timed to coincide with ORG Day, which now falls every year on 19 November to celebrate the formaton of Open Rights Group. Please come and get involved! If you're short on time then just come along to The Duke for a drink at around 2000.

Press relations

Every week, we spend time talking to the media and connecting them with experts or giving an alternate point of view on current issues. Please see the press archive for more details.

  • openDemocracy - 'Digital privacy wars'
  • Guy Aitchison discusses two approaches to Phorm's behavioural marketing techniques. For Peter Bazalgette, advertising is vital to expand the internet economy whilst privacy campaigners fail to see the importance of commerce. ORG responds to this criticism by showing why online commercial relationships need to be private too.

  • PC Pro - 'E-voting vetoed for 2009 election'
  • Stuart Turton reports on Michael Wills', minister of state for the Ministry of Justice, formal announcement that Government "does not plan to introduce e-voting for the 2009 European or local elections." ORG is pretty darn chuffed that our long-running campaign to highlight the risks with electronic elections is being taken seriously.

  • Macworld - 'UK slows down plan for sweeping electronic surveillance'
  • Jeremy Kirk covers Home Office plans for legislation to support a database of all communications data, which is being delayed to allow for proper public debate. ORG is pleased the issue will be consulted on because "creating this database would drastically alter the relationship between the citizen and the state, handing national security and law enforcement agencies immense power to invade the private lives of ordinary people."

  • The Guardian - 'Democracy needs spontaneity'
  • John Ozimek comments on our contribution to Freedom Not Fear, an international day of activities publicising the gradual drift towards surveillance socieites. Our involvement, for John anyway, was more of an arts event than a demonstration because the police required "reasonable notice". Democracy and the political process are seriously at risk when spontaneous assemblies and marches are outlawed.


The very best way to stay updated on ORG-esque events is with our Upcoming group. Here are some particularly exciting events happening in the next month or so:

  • 'Onemedia Unconference '
  • Onemedia is a pioneering unconference where you set the agenda to find the cross industry business opportunities that matter to you, to increase your revenue and develop your business model. London, 13 and 14 November 2008.

  • ORG Xmas Party
  • The ORG Xmas Party will be on Saturday 20 December. The only guarantee at this advance stage is for yuletide jocularity. Reserve your ticket now and send in any suggestions for party games and related bagatelle.

    Update: We've had to take the tough decision to call it off, because the low uptake from both sponsors and guests means that if we went ahead, ORG would be at risk of making a significant financial loss.

    We do however have two alternative nights out for you. Hopefully you'll be able to make at least one of them, so we can celebrate the festive season together and look forward to a fab year ahead for ORG.

    First, ORG is a co-host for the Privacy and Civil Liberties Community Christmas Party, which you are all cordially invited to. It will be at The 'Quad Bar' of the London School of Economics' "Three Tuns Pub", Houghton Street, London, WC2A 2AE on Thursday 11 December from 1800 to 2300. RSVP to gus at privacy dot org.

    Second, the ORG staff will be delighted to meet supporters who are still up for an Xmas drink on Saturday 20 December from 1930 at our local, which is The Duke - - 7 Roger Street, London, WC1N 2PB. Mail supporters at openrightsgroup dot org if you're coming so we can me sure there's enough space.

    Mini-links: Intercept Modernisation


Thanks to Felix, Glyn, Sheila, Casey, James and Patricia for running the Gaiman event. Thanks to Sam, Rowan and Casey for putting together our "data debacles" tool. Thanks to Chris and Adam for working on ORG's facebook profile. Thanks to Adam for doing lots and lots and lots ... and lots. Thanks to Tom, Chris, James, Harry and the many others who worked on the Freedom Not Fear demo. Thanks to James for stuffing envelopes. Thanks to Matt N and Glyn for newsblogging. Thanks to Jonty, Chris, Casbon and Matt P for getting into the supporter database. Finally, thanks to the Board and Advisory and our hard working staff for all they do.

[Read more]

September 30, 2008 | Michael Holloway

Supporter update - September 2008

Welcome to the latest Open Rights Group supporter update.

In this edition:

- Freedom Not Fear: community photocall - - ORG-GRO: Asus Eee PC giveaway - - Board recruitment - - Consultations - - Volunteer meeting - - Press - - Events - - Mini Links - - Thanks -


  • Freedom Not Fear: community photocall
  • We need you to take photos that embody the database state and the UK’s world-famous surveillance society. On 11 October, as part of Freedom Not Fear Day 2008, No2ID and the Open Rights Group will make a live collage in a prominent location in London (to be confirmed) of the images you've supplied. Freedom not Fear is an international day of action for democracy, free speech, human rights and civil liberties, and events to celebrate these central tenets of a just society will be taking place all over the world.

    Here's how to help: 1. Spot something that embodies the UK’s wholesale transformation into the surveillance society/database state. Subjects might include your local CCTV camera(s), or fingerprinting equipment in your child’s school library; 2. Snap it; 3. Upload it to Flickr and tag it “FNFBigPicture” (please use an Attribution Creative Commons licence). Check out the growing gallery of surveillance society images here.

  • ORG-GRO: Asus Eee PC giveaway
  • Our supporter drive continued in September with Who's Watching Who, a video produced to encourage the ORG community to recruit more supporters for ORG, and a series of book giveaways. The widgetometer has climbed steadily towards 1,000 but we all need to be more active to hit the target of 1,500 fivers per month by the end of the year. Currently Tom Reynolds is our top recruiter and so in pole position to win an Asus Eee PC, with Glyn, Sheila, Richard, Simon and Danny snapping at his heels. Please follow their lead by encouraging like-minded sorts to support ORG and digital rights. And an admin note: be sure that any new supporters you recruit mention your name on the webform so we can keep track.

  • ORG seeks Directors
  • The ORG Board of Directors is responsible for overseeing all aspects of our work, from payroll to policy decisions. We have a committed and expert group of volunteer non-executive Directors and with the organisation approaching its third birthday are seeking new additions to join the team. There is more information about the role on the blog, including the particular skills sought and commitments involved, together with a more detailed job description. Applicants have until 28 October 2008 to send their CV to michael at openrightsgroup dot org.

  • Consultations
  • ORG authored a submission to the Ministry of Justice's Weekend Voting consultation, explaining the significant risks posed by remote electronic voting to our democracy. We're now collecting comments on the Government's plans to oblige ISPs to take action against subscribers to their network who infringe copyright. Please help us respond.

  • Volunteer meeting reminder
  • The upcoming volunteer meet on 9 October will be a little more involved than usual, including a brainstorm for an overhaul of our website. Also, happily, we're expecting a lot of new faces who've learned about our interests and works over the Summer. Please add your name to the wiki page if you're planning to attend and feel free to add suggested works to the draft agenda.

Press relations

Every week, we spend time talking to the media and connecting them with experts or giving an alternate point of view on current issues. Please see the press archive for more details.

  • Ars Technica - 'EU Parliament: Only judges can order 'Net disconnections'' Nate Anderson continues to bravely follow the Telecom Package through the EU Parliament, reporting both good news and bad for Netizens. MEPs rejected an amendment that, in our view, would have prevented EU member states requiring local ISPs to filter content. The Parliament did however approve text requiring judicial oversight for any disconnection procedure. This amendment should prohibit a graduated response approach, whereby Big Content is given control of our connections.
  • Out-Law - 'Copyright changes would only earn fifty cents a year for artists, say activists' Reporting our analysis of the proposed term extension in sound recordings, Out-Law emphasises the additional annual earnings due to accrue to perfomers (between 59 cents and €26.79 per year) and major labels (€200,000 to €4.1 million a year). Out-Law also repeat our concern that this extension will further damage public perception of copyright but not benefit artists and their fans.
  • New Statesman - 'Joining the Lib Dems...' Ben Davies describes the view from the Lib Dem conference in Bournemouth, where Becky spoke on digital equality. Apparently the audience were more interested in discussing our priority issue of downloading music and copyright than the suggested topic. Becky has also featured on New Statesman panels at the Labour and Conservative conferences, using the opportunity to collar grassroots party members to chat about digital rights.


    The very best way to stay updated on ORG-esque events is with our Upcoming group. Here are some some particularly exciting events happening in the next month or so:

  • Piracy vs Obscurity: Neil Gaiman, famed post-modern author and patron of ORG, on the first public appearance of his Graveyard Book UK tour, invites fans and ORG supporters to discuss piracy from the perspective of a creator, what it means to be one of the tribe of readers, and why most people discover their favourite authors for free. Friday 24 October, London.
  • Open Source for Games Developers - A Debate on New Business Models: We've linked up with Own-It to host an event for the London Games Fringe: the panel, chaired by Becky, will feature veterans of law, code and business. Tuesday 28 October, London
Mini-links: With Phorm back in the news, read on to protect you and your users

Thanks Thanks to everyone who's chipped in during September. Thanks to David, Harry, Tom and Patrick for running our stall at the Green Party Conference. Thanks to James C, Chris and Fred for running our stall at PyCon. Thanks to James H for producing our banner stand. Thanks to Glyn for doing a talk at BarCamp London and to Felix for doing the same at BarCamp Bath. Thanks to Lemon, Mike, Sam and Adam for keeping the site live and direct. Thanks to Alaric for setting up a digital rights event in Bristol. Thanks to JonRob for interning to the fullness. Thanks to Harry for working on a maps mashup. Last but not least, thanks to Becky, Gavin and the usual suspects on the Board and Advisory Council.

[Read more]

August 29, 2008 | Michael Holloway

Supporter update - August 2008

Welcome to the latest Open Rights Group supporter update. In this edition:

- Sound Copyright - - Neil Gaiman event - - Supporter drive - - p2p Consulation - - Volunteer meeting - - Press - - Events - - Mini Links - - Thanks -


  • Copyright extension would not aid artists, citizens or the economy
  • The UK Intellectual Property Office wanted comments on the EC proposal to extend copyright term protection on sound recordings. Our report dissects the flimsy proposal and accompanying impact assessment to reveal minimal benefits for social welfare and inclusion. And, shock horror, the predicted benefits would accrue only to the biggest record labels, not to artists or record-buyers. The proposal ignores the growing evidence base in favour of reducing terms and, according to Europe's most prominent copyright thinker, misleads both policy-makers and citizens. For much more on this issue see the Sound Copyright site.

  • Piracy v Obscurity - an evening with Neil Gaiman
  • We're excited to announce a special event with Neil Gaiman, best-selling author and ORG patron. On Friday 24 October, Neil will talk about what it means to be one of the tribe of readers, and why most people discover their favourite authors for free. Entry is free to new supporters of ORG who join between now and the event. Existing ORG supporters will be charged a discount rate of £5 and the general public will be asked the full price of £10. More details and tickets over on Eventbrite.

  • Its been a solid month for our supporter drive, with sustainable donations pushing up above the 900 fivers per month mark, which is good but still not enough so please help us reach the 1,500 target by browbeating your buddies into becoming supporters. The incentives of an Asus Eec PC for top referrer are still available, as is the offer of a mystery gift for supporters who either join at or raise their donation to ten pounds a month. Next month we'll be giving away more books and (fingers crossed) releasing a supporter-powered promotional video.

  • Guv consultation on illicit p2p
  • The war on illicit p2p continues, but how many civilian casualties will it claim? Guv wants a code of practice designed by ISPs and rightsholders in collaboration with OfCom that will oblige ISPs to take action against subscribers to their network who infringe copyright over p2p. Is this is a workable approach? What remedies should be available to rightholders? The deadline is 30 October 2008 but we need your comments *now* to produce a coherent and evidentially solid report. Please use our interactive comments tool to tell us what you think.

  • Volunteers meeting
  • Last night's August volunteer meetup was a little subdued but welcoming enough for a couple of first-timers. See the minutes for more detail and various tasks that need taking on. Our next volunteer meeting is scheduled for 9 October: please sign up on the wiki if you'll be coming along.

Press relations

Every week, we spend time talking to the media and connecting them with experts or giving an alternate point of view on current issues. Please see the press archive for more details.

  • The Register / Kablenet - 'Electoral Commission criticises London e-counting'
  • Our concerns over a lack of transparency and security in London's recent Mayoral poll have now been fully vindicated by this Electoral Commission report. The elections watchdog expressed "significant concerns about the use of electronic counting for elections in the UK" and called for proper analysis of the "costs and benefits of both electronic and manual options for counting ballot papers before the next GLA elections in 2012."

  • BBC - 'Game sharers face legal crackdown'
  • A test case judgement ordered £16,000 of damages for seeding a filesharing network with a video game. Lawyers acting for the firm gleefully predicted there will be many more similar cases. Although this open court process is preferable to private justice administered behind closed doors, the extreme weight of the fine seems disproportionate. See below for more commentary on this case.

  • Reuters - 'Is file-sharing morally wrong?'<>/li> Peter Griffiths, inspired by the filesharing decision (see above and below), riffs on the boom in swapping music, films or TV programmes. He notes that copyright infringement is not the same as theft because the owner is not deprived of their property and uses ORG as authority for the claim that this crackdown will drive filesharing underground and make it even harder for rights holders to earn a crust.
Events - Manc special!

The very best way to stay updated on ORG-esque events is with our Upcoming group. Here's some some particularly exciting events happening in the next month or so:

  • 'Privacy and Security in the Database State'
  • The Manchester branch of the BCS, in conjunction with Manchester NO2ID, are organising a public meeting on 23 September in Manchester. Becky has been asked to speak alongside Phil Booth of No2id.

  • 'mySociety Manchester meetup'
  • "Informally covering the range of remotely mySociety antics, and anything else we fancy". Wednesday 17 September.

  • 'Manchester 2600 Computer Security Meeting'
  • On the first Friday of every month, aimed at everybody with an interest in computer security, telephony, hacking, phone phreaking, cryptography, internet security/privacy issues and related subjects. Friday 5 September.
Mini-links Thanks

Belated thanks to Gavin for joining the ORG staff and JonRob for being a terrifical intern. Thanks to Sheila, Harry, Adam, Lemon, Sam, Glyn, Chris and all the other regulars. Thanks to James for his design work, to Patrick for the holiday guide. Much thanks to the Board and Advisory Council. And last of all, thanks to Becky, who just don't stop!

[Read more]

July 31, 2008 | Michael Holloway

Supporter update - July 2008

Welcome to the latest Open Rights Group supporter update.


  • ORG-GRO: building up to sustainability
  • We've launched an ambitious supporter drive, aimed at achieving financial sustainability by increasing our individual donations from 750 to 1,500 fivers per month. The campaign launched at Open Tech and will continue through the rest of 2008 with a series of events and happenings. It's been a strong start: we've already reached 825 fivers. We've got a fundometer and prizes, including an Asus Eee PC, for supporters who increase their own donations and encourage their pals to support ORG. Get in touch if you have suggestions to help us reach our ambitious target.

  • Term Extension: 'we don't need no expert advice'
  • As a result of intense lobbying, the EU Commission disregarded the balance of evidence and formally accepted the proposal to extend the duration of copyright for sound recordings. The proposal now goes to the European Parliament. David Rowntree and prominent academics have already joined ORG in rebuffing the idea. There are three ways for you to help our Sound Copyright campaign. Please, if you have not already, sign and spread our petition; help us critique the Commission proposal and impact assessment; finally, express your views to the UK Intellectual Property Office's informal consultation.

  • Elections Report 2008
  • Our report into the e-counting of votes cast in the London Elections found "insufficient evidence" to declare confidence in the result. Besides voicing our fundamental transparency and security concerns, we called for a full cost benefit analysis of any future e-count, set against a properly costed manual count. Despite the continued obduracy of the Ministry of Justice, the latest word from the Electoral Commission backs our conclusions and vindicates our cautionary stance. Huge thanks to all the observers who put in hard work and long hours to make this report possible. Thanks also to Jason Kitcat for presenting to the GLA Electoral Review Committee.

  • Towards legislating against illicit filesharing
  • Activity on various fronts this month in the 'war on sharing'. The biggest noise came over a Government-brokered agreement, signed by the UK's six major ISPs and entertainment industry rightsholders. Its stated objective is a significant reduction in illicit filesharing and a change in popular attitudes towards copyright infringement. The agreement was published within a consultation into legislation aimed at curbing illicit filesharing on the net, which we'll be responding to in due course. Typically, the emphasis is on enforcement, with a lack of care and attention for new services and business models that would encourage consumers back onto the right side of legality. See the press roundup below for more comment from ORG on this agreement.

  • Newsblog brings you the latest digital rights stories
  • The ORG newsblog, which has now been ticking over for a few months, is maintained by volunteers as an up-to-the-minute feed of digital rights stories. You can follow it by RSS or twitter. We need you guys to suggest stories for posting so please send suggestions either to or by tagging content 'openrightsgroup' on Also, if you can lend a hand with actually posting to the blog, please drop us a line to the same address. Most of the graft so far on newsblog has been down to Richard King, who deserves a special round of applause and a beer if you see him out and about.

  • Volunteers meeting
  • The July volunteer meeting was a little quieter than usual, maybe because it's holiday season, but we did allocate a whole heap of new work and celebrate the increased productivity of our volunteer corps. It really does feel like more people are getting involved and working on a wider range of activities for us. The date for our next meeting is set as Thursday 28 August.

Press relations

Every week, we spend time talking to the media and connecting them with experts or giving an alternate point of view on current issues. This was another bumper month for press coverage: at least 66 news sources around the world (including the Sun!) ran with an Associated Press article on filesharing featuring an ORG quote. Please see our July 2008 press archive for more details.

  • Guardian - 'London mayoral election: doubts over 41,000 votes counted by machine' Bobbie Johnson eloquently amplified our concern that London's electoral system involves an "unacceptable level of uncertainty" and our call for a "proper cost-benefit analysis of whether it's worth using electronic counting at all."
  • Ars Technica - 'Experts attack Big Content's EU copyright power-grab' - Nate Anderson reports on the plan to retroactively add 45 years of copyright protection to old sound recordings. Academics say the benefits will accrue to "record companies, aging rock stars or, increasingly, artists' estates. It does nothing for innovation and creativity." The piece also quotes our warning against "the traps of faith based policy and voodoo economics that simply grant IP rightsholders requests for more."
  • BBC Radio 4 Today Programme - 'Internet firms tackle music piracy': The announcement that Guv has brokered a deal between ISPs and rights holders to limit illegal filesharing meant we finally broke our duck on the Today programme. Alongside Billy Bragg and DCMS Minister Andy Burnham, Becky took the stage like an old hand, calmly calling for a consumer voice to enter these negotiations.
  • The Telegraph - 'Parents face fines if children illegally download music or films from web': Robert Winnett and Nicole Martin point out that parents's internet viewing will be restricted if their children continue to illegally download music or films under a Government-backed crackdown. The ORG quote suggests disconnection is a harsh and poorly-targetted punishment, which will drive illicit activity even further underground.


The very best way to stay updated on ORG-esque events is with our Upcoming group. Here's some some particularly exciting events happening in the next month or so:

  • Geek In the Park: "Join us on Saturday 9th August 2008 for an all-day family event including a relaxing picnic & a discussion with leaders in the web industry in the evening." Leamington Spa, England.
  • Bar Camp Leeds: "Come join us at Old Broadcasting House again, this time for two days of geekery and (hopefully) great weather on the 16th and 17th of August 2008!"
  • dConstruct: "an affordable, one-day conference aimed at those designing and building the latest generation of social web applications." 3 - 5 September 2008


  • It seems that years of campaigning are finally paying off and Guv are trying to be more open. The leaders of the new school are Power of Information (PoI) Taskforce, who are helping government become more transparent and effective through better use of published information.
  • Their flagship project - Show Us a Better Way - calls for ideas for new products to improve the way public information is communicated, with a £20,000 prize fund to develop the best ideas.
  • Our good pals at the Ministry of Justice are getting in on the act now, with 10 £15k grants for projects that will reignite people's passion for democracy or the democratic process.
  • This related beta service encourages re-use of public sector information. Tell them what you want unlocked, and they'll get on it. Impressive!

Thanks to Dan Ray for being a superb intern. Thanks to Casbon and Cronin for the donations of hardware that meant we could upgrade from 1990s to 2000s machinery; thanks to Adam for installing the goods. Thanks to Glyn, Sheila and Richard for repping the ORG at LUG Radio Live. Thanks to the audio monkeys (Tom, Rowan, Mark and Dan) for helping us to help UKUUG and record Open Tech. Thanks to Anne, Mark and Rowan for the 'one-sheets'. Thanks to Lemon and Mike for keeping us online and even moving forward a little bit. Thanks to Sheila for starting work on a redesign of our website. Thanks to Glyn, who is always on the case for us. Thanks to Harry for something or other. Thanks to anyone who is using our widget. Big ups to the Board and Advisory Council.

[Read more]

June 30, 2008 | Michael Holloway

Supporter update - June 2008


  • London Elections Report

The ORG report into the May 2008 London e-count will be published this week. Keep an eye on our blog to read the report in full.

  • ORG's European Vacation

News that the European Commission may soon formally propose an extension to copyright term on sound recordings sent Becky and Gavin off to Brussels to speak with key policy makers. Packed in their suitcases: passports; smart suits; a petition signed by over 11,000 Europeans asking the Commission to consider the views of citizens and consumers, and not just powerful rightsholders; and a letter of objection drafted by the continent's most respected intellectual property thinkers. The fight for Sound Copyright continues!

  • Open Tech 2008

Open Tech "is an informal, low cost one-day conference on technology, society and low-carbon living, featuring Open Source ways of working and technologies that anyone can have a go at." The ORG was conceived at Open Tech 2005. This year we're leading two of the morning sessions, a keysigning party and will be meeting with supporters in the bar once the formal sessions have finished, at around 19.30. See the programme for more details on all the sessions. And please, if you're coming down, make sure to join us for a drink and give ORG volunteers and staff a heads up on the digital rights issues you're concerned with.

  • The Future of the Internet in Focus

Will consumer pressure for a safer net mean the end of open platforms and rapid innovation? And should the geeks who "get" the net care if the rest of the world prefer TiVos and iPhones? This month we co-hosted an event at the British Computer Society to discuss the problems raised by Jonathan Zittrain's new book, The Future of the Internet and How to Stop It. Professor Zittrain was joined by technology journalist Bill Thompson and Becky Hogge to discuss the threat that insecurity and "tethered appliances" pose to the generative internet. We were also fortunate enough to have an expert and lively audience. The recording (click to listen) shows the broad range of views within our community.

  • Volunteers meeting

June's volunteer meeting was a boisterous but productive session, with the usual mix of issues discussion and apportioning of duties, followed by a friendly ale. The next meeting is scheduled for Thursday 24 July, please indicate on the wiki if you want to join in.

Press relations

Every week, we spend time talking to the media and connecting them with experts or giving an alternate point of view on current issues. Please see our June 2008 press archive for more details

A service enabling users to locate friends to within a radius of a few hundred metres and costing 50p a time will soon be available on Facebook, reports Andrea-Marie Vassou. Our concern here is that the privacy risks associated with publicising location data are not recognised by the general public, especially in the context of social networks where the concept of friend is meaningless.

Virgin are sending warning letters to broadband customers suspected of illegally sharing music files. Although there is no threat to disconnect, users are told they "need to stop or face action". According to Simon Aughton, the BPI and the Government welcome the approach. Our concern that file sharers will switch to using encrypted protocols to evade detection is quoted.

David Hepworth notes the varying responses from ISPs to the record industry's demands to tackle copyright infringement online and compensate them for the unauthorised use of their products. He's not convinced a music tax should be levied because every other sector of the entertainment industry, starting with sporting and movie right holders, will be next in line.


The very best way to stay updated on ORG-esque events is with our Upcoming group. Here's some some particularly exciting events happening in the next month or so:

  • LUG Radio Live UK 2008 includes sessions on free software, Open Source, digital rights, technology and more, a compelling list of speakers, exhibitors and birds of a feather sessions. Described as combining the atmosphere of a rock concert and a computer conference!

  • UKGovWeb Teacamp is a gathering for people working in and around UK government with a particular interest in government online. It happens twice a month, on the first and third Thursdays.

Mini Links: Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA)


Thanks to Mike, Lemon and Adam for keeping the site running. Thanks to Chris, Fred, James and Dean for helping with our supporter drive tools. Thanks to Patrick, Rowan, Mark, Anne Onn, Sheila, Glyn, Adam, Chris, Rachel, Richard and Elliot for participating in the June volunteer meet and getting busy on their alloted tasks. Thanks to Raph for getting involved with the wiki. Thanks to Felix for recording our event at the BCS. Thanks to the Observers who helped Becky to draft our 2008 Elections Report. Gracious thanks to the Board and Advisory Council. And last of all, thanks to Becky, Gavin and Dan for doing 'most everything else.

[Read more]

May 30, 2008 | Michael Holloway

Supporter update - May 2008


  1. Election Observers
  2. The 2008 Election Observers performed their duties to perfection earlier this month, keeping a watchful eye on the electronic count of the London elections. Their individual reports will be combined to produce our official report, which will be published in late June. Although the administration of the e-count was an improvement on the (near-disastrous) 2007 elections, our fundamental concerns around transparency remain.

  3. Floreat ORG
  4. We are delighted to announce new additions to the Open Rights Group office. Gavin Hill has been appointed as our new Policy Officer to work at the European level against copyright term extension and the "three strikes" agenda. We also welcome Daniel Ray for a two-month internship. He will be focussing on network neutrality issues - if you want to help him out please do so via the wiki or drop a line to daniel at openrightsgroup dot org. Meanwhile, our founding Executive Director Suw Charman is moving on from the ORG Board of Directors to concentrate on new projects, and Louise Ferguson is stepping down as Chair of the Board, although she will continue as a Director. Suw and Louise brought vast energy and expertise over the last three years and we cannot thank them enough for their contributions.

  5. Consultations
  6. We're working towards two consultations this month and ask you to inform our submissions. If you care about how the public service obligations imposed on the BBC and other brodcasters are reformed for the digital age then please have your say on either consult or the wiki. The other ongoing consultation is a review of consumer protection regulation, whose remit includes regulation of DRM and the enforcement of intellectual property rights. Again, please respond through the wiki or consult.

  7. Volunteers meeting
  8. Unfortunately we had to cancel the May volunteer meeting but are excited for the rescheduled meeting on 12 June. The main item on the agenda will be our network neutrality briefing pack, so anyone with a particular interest in that issue really should join in. As usual, we'll run the IRC channel to include those unable to join us in London. And if you'd like a conference call as well, please indicate on the wiki.

Press relations

Every week, we spend time talking to the media and connecting them with experts or giving an alternate point of view on current issues. There are too many great press stories to link here, including mentions on Channel 4, ITV, the Daily Mail, the Telegraph and the Times. Please see our May 2008 press archive for more details.

The Sun - 'Beeb tries to extermi-knit' ORG scored major press exposure this month by helping out with a peculiarly British story of overzealous copyright protection involving the BBC's premier export, Doctor Who, and an allegedly infringing knitting pattern. See mini-links below for the full story. Colin Robertson's report seemed especially noteworth for being ORG's first mention in the 'nation's favourite newspaper'.

Experian Q&S / Data Quality News - 'Data Quality News on employees 'black list'' A database is in development for busineses to report dishonesty amongst employees, and for prospective employers to trawl for dirt on recruitment candidates. We're on hand to point out the database will encourage prejudice and abuse against workplace activits and whistleblowers.


The very best way to stay updated on ORG-esque events is with our Upcoming group. Here's some some particularly exciting events happening in the next month or so:

The Future of the Internet in Focus is an event we're co-hosting at the British Computer Society on 4 June, featuring Jonathan Zittrain and Bill Thompson. Unfortunately its fully booked now but fear not as we'll make an audio recording available.

Open Tech 2008 is "an informal, low cost one-day conference on technology, society and low-carbon living, featuring Open source ways of working and technologies." We're very excited that Danny O'Brien will be presenting on our behalf and hope to see many of you guys there.



Thanks to Daniel and Gavin for joining the party. Thanks to Mike, Lemon and Adam for fiddling with our website. Thanks to Caroline, Glyn, David and Louise for representing both ORG and No2ID at the Dulwich fair. Thanks to the 2008 Observers: Glyn, Stef, Suw, Robin, Gervase, Lucy, Rona, Daryl, Ian, Ben, Alex, Alex, Taylor, Adrian, Loretta, Caroline, James, Louise, Harry, Felix, Jonathan, AJ, Dave, Susanne, James and Chris. Thanks to Casbon for further efforts on SuppDB. Thanks to the newsbloggers: Glyn, Harry, Mark and Richard. Humble thanks to the Board and Advisory Council. And last of all, thanks to Becky, whose great efforts go largely unappreciated. Oh, and thanks to you for reading this far!

[Read more]

May 30, 2008 | Mike Little

Supporters update - September 2005

(First Beta Edition - Do Not Use On Children or The Elderly)

Welcome to the latest Open Rights Group supporters update email.

Pledge now stands at 865 founding members:


  • Boring AdministriviaDull technicalities such as arranging a bank account, free office space, a budget and grant applications continue apace. After several press inquiries addressed to "your digital rights thing", a name was chosen: the OPEN RIGHTS GROUP. Acclaimed as "okay", it served its principal purpose, which was to delay incorporation while the Secretary of State personally checks whether we are, technically, a "group": a special term, it turns out, in company law. No, we're not joking. Explanation of what ORG will do:,3605,1537039,00.html
  • You don't need us to tell you that the mandatory retention of data about every EU citizen's calls, mobile phone movements, and internet usage would be a bad thing (if you do, check for a joint letter from EDRi and Privacy International to the Council of Ministers on the problems with data retention).

    But it's happening anyway: the EU Commission just published their proposal to do just that:

    And there's a live streaming press conference with Commissioner for Justice, Freedom and Security Franco Frattini on the 'retention of data and the radicalisation and recruitment of terrorists' today (Wednesday 21 Sept) at 12.15pm.

    One of the key EU institutions considering their position on this proposal is the ARTICLE 29 WORKING GROUP: that's all of the Information Commissioners (data protection registrars) in the EU, acting as one.

    Word has it that many of the Article 29 Working Group want to fight data retention.

    But the UK Information Commissioner says he can't join the fight because he doesn't feel that he can publically stand against the UK government's recent paper "Liberty and Security: Striking the Right Balance".

    Short summary: it has a CCTV picture of the London Bombers on the front page. Says civil liberties are nice and all but, woo, terrorism.

    Longer summary (from the excellent Privacy International coverage):[347]=x-347-346410

    EDRi has produced a short analysis of the paper, which finds that none of the examples used by the UK government would justify their data retention proposals:

    The latest draft of the EU's data retention plans have already excised the Article 29 working group from overseeing what sort of data gets retained.

    The group want to fight, but the UK commissioner is reticent.

    You can get them fighting back. Tell your Info Commissioner to stand up for your rights.


    Visit and sign European Digital Rights (EDRi)'s Europe-wide petition. EDRi is working hard at the EU level to alert politicians to the issues with data retention; the petition helps it demonstrate the size of the constituency it represents and will help boost Article 29's confidence.


    The UK Information Commissioner doesn't answer to the government: he answers to Parliament, and from them, to you. His mission (should he choose to accept it) includes: "protecting your personal information".

    For that he doesn't need the government's backing: he needs yours.

    1. Write to your MP, and tell him or her that you want the UK Information Commissioner to speak in the EU on your behalf against data retention. Use

    2. When you're done, copy and paste your message to the Commissioner's office email at: If you like, cc: us at

    (You may want to check before you send that second mail. We want the information commissioner to know we support him, but don't want to spam him to death. If he complains, we'll put up a sign.)

    3. Forward this mail. Feel free to cut out everything but this plea. But make sure you include the expiry date: THURSDAY 2005-09-22.

    Here's some points you could mention in your letter to your MP:

    * Ask your MP to tell the Information Commissioner to speak for you, not the British government. Your right to have your personal data protected will outlast the current incumbents and must be assured by the appropriate legislation.

    * The Commissioner has previously commented on both the expense of and lack of need for data retention. Ask your MP to ask that he fully and thoroughly investigate any data retention plans before rolling them out across Europe. Try not to mention "45 minute claims": it makes MPs uncomfortable and sweaty.

    * The "Liberty and Security" paper published by the government actually only asks for "internet logins and logouts". The EU proposal also demands the To: and From: of emails. Tell your MP that even if the Commissioner is beholden to the government's stance, he should agree to no more than the minimum amount of data requested.

    Be polite; be pursuasive: we want him on our side.

    But most of all, be prompt. The Article 29 Working Group meets Thursday and Friday of this week.

    We'll let you know how you get on. Remember, 850 people have your back.

  • Free Culture UK - Grassroots Action for The Public DomainFree Culture UK is a grassroots organisation that campaigns for key creative freedoms: a vibrant public domain, open formats, and free licenses. On October 1st, they're meeting up for their first Congress to set their agenda for the next year. If you're near London, you should pop along. If you're not, FC-UK has local groups in Birmingham, Brighton, Deptford, Exeter, Leeds and Reading - and can advise you on how to start your own.
  • Open GeoData Campaign Gets a MonkeyItching to chuck a fiver before the Open Rights Group pledge matures? The Pledge to support open access to state-collected geospatial data matured last week. They're collecting names to make sure that when you get tax-funded maps, you *really* get them: free for use and redistribution. And they're not sitting on their backsides waiting either: the OPENSTREETMAP project is creating a body of free data collected from geohackers all over the world. The pledge should earn them 500UKP, but a few more fivers wouldn't go amiss:See what they've done: Find out why they're doing it: Paypal fivers or offers of help to:

Are you doing something that defends or extends digital rights? Want more people to know about it? Worried about an issue that no-one has spotted yet? Tell us via the comments section.

Groups mentioned: - 15 years fighting for privacy - 21 orgs, 14 countries - the free wiki world map - grassroots for an open culture - because your rights are reserved

[Read more]

April 30, 2008 | Michael Holloway

Supporter update - April 2008


  1. ORG is hiring
  2. We're looking for an experienced and committed digital rights campaigner to work on issues around copyright reform and infringement, taking the concerns of ORG and its supporters to Europe and beyond. The job description includes full details of the role, the particular issues involved and how to apply. Note that the deadline for applications is Sunday 11 May and interviews will take place 14 - 16 May. We could not have timed this better with the European Parliament showing sympathy for digital rights concerns twice in the past month, first by rejecting the "three strikes" enforment system and then voting against criminalisation of file-sharing. For more on the unfolding "three strikes" saga, see mini-links below.

  3. ElectionWatch '08
  4. ORG's election observers (class of 2008) are in the final stages of preparing to monitor the e-counted aspects of the London elections. Last year, after chaotic scenes in polling stations and count centres, ORG wrote a highly critical report of the e-voting and e-counting pilots, and the Electoral Commission called for a halt to e-voting and e-counting in the UK. Just under 30 officially accredited ORG observers will be scrutinising the e-count this year.

  5. Newsblog
  6. We now have a blog devoted to digital rights stories. Thanks to our diligent and news-hungry volunteers, the posts are coming out thick and fast, ranging from the Earl of Errol's musing on data breaches to the PR-gaff-of-the-month from Virgin Media's CEO. If you have a suggestion for a story then please submit it by email to newsbloggers at openrightsgroup dot org so our collective of authors can consider it for postage. Or you can point us to your story with the 'openrightsgroup' tag on And if you'd like to help out by blogging for ORG then hit reply and let us know.

  7. Consultations
  8. The role of public service broadcasting is up for review as Ofcom ask for input on how to adapt the PSB funding model to keep up with the Internet. As usual, we want your help with our submission through either orgwiki or Consult, so please please please have a read of the consultation materials and get involved. Also, earlier this month, we submitted to the UK-IPO's consultation on (Gowers') exceptions to copyright, emphasising the need for a user-friendly private copying exception and a right to parody as well as calling for fresh analysis of the transformative works issue. Read the submission in full on orgwiki (6) or in PDF. PS Rumours abound that Consult will be seconded to the Department for Innovation, Universities and Skills.

  9. Volunteer meeting
  10. April's volunteer meeting was a reflective affair involving updates of ongoing works and a discussion of ideas for future fundraising and corporate engagement. Thanks especially to the new faces who joined our regular crew. Next up is Thursday 15 May, please indicate on the wiki if you want to join us.

Press relations

Every week, we spend time talking to the media and connecting them with experts or giving them an alternate point of view on current issues.

The media coverage of Phorm became even more hostile after BT admitted 'spying' on thousands of its broadband customers. This story reports our view that the behavioural advertising system was potentially illegal, based on excellent analysis by two of the ORG advisory council, Nicholas Bohm and Richard Clayton, wearing their Foundation for Information Policy Research millinery.

ORG joined Statewatch, Privacy International and 40 other campaign bodies from around Europe to support Ireland's case against the Data Retention Directive. The law, which requires telecommunications companies to keep records of customers' communications for up to two years, should be rejected because it breaches our fundamental human rights of privacy and freedom of expression.

    Blogs and news sites around the world picked up on our report of this month's watershed moment, when the European Parliament rejected Internet filtering and draconian anti-piracy measures. In particular, our comment that the vote "signifies resistance among MEPs to measures currently being implemented in France to disconnect suspected illicit filesharers" was used again and again.

Drew Wilson posted on our latest call for a private copyright exception, which argued for a broad right that matched consumer's expectations for the music they buy. The post links our arguments with concerns recently expressed by William Patry, an eminent US copyright theorist, who rejected the view that any private copying exception should be narrowly defined and compensated by a levy on the sale of blank media devices.

Commenting on our scrutiny of the electronic count for this week's London elections, we argue that using computers in this context frustrates transparency and independent oversight. The piece goes on to cite a new report that these technologies increase costs and further undermine confidence in the electoral process yet do not increase voter turnout

Events The very best way to stay updated on ORG-esque events is with our Upcoming group. Here's some some particularly exciting events happening in the next month or so:

UKNOF10 takes place in Wolverhampton on 21 May - "The United Kingdom Network Operators' Forum (UKNOF) acts as an open forum for operational, technical and engineering information exchange related to backbone networking technologies and practices."

The 18th Computers, Freedom and Privacy conference takes place in New Haven, CT, USA on 20 - 23 May

Mini-links: "Three strikes" reportage


Thanks to everyone who joined the volunteer meeting this month: Mark, Chris, Chris, Frederik, Anon., Adam, Glyn, Rowan, Harry, Robin, Howard, Raph, Dynamo_Ace and Elliotjhug. Thanks to the 2008 Observers: Glyn, Stef, Suw, Robin, Gervase, Lucy, Rona, Daryl, Ian, Ben, Alex, Alex, Taylor, Adrian, Loretta, Caroline, James, Louise, Harry, Felix, Jonathan, AJ, Dave, Susanne, James and Chris. Thanks to the newsbloggers: Glyn, Harry and Mark. Thanks to Jordan and Lilian for working on the next big thing. Ta very much to the Board and Advisory Council. And last of all, thanks to Becky, who runs this show. Oh, and thanks to anyone i neglected.

[Read more]